State fights Trump administration’s attempt to lift ban on disposable camping propane canisters
By Bob Egelko
California is going to court to defend its plan to prohibit sales of single-use propane canisters that fuel campers’ stoves, a ban that the Trump administration derides as part of the state’s “climate scam.”
In a filing Thursday with a federal appeals court in Washington, D.C., state Attorney General Rob Bonta’s office said it would challenge the Trump administration’s claim that a state law ending sales of the single-use canisters in 2028 conflicts with federal laws and regulations on hazardous waste.
The law, Senate Bill 1280 by Sen. John Laird, D-Santa Cruz, was passed in 2024 with support from local governments and waste-management groups.
Backers of the law say the 1-pound, hand-held canisters — of which more than 4 million are sold in California each year — are often discarded after use and wind up in waste facilities where they can explode. Consumers and the environment, supporters say, will benefit by switching to reusable cylinders, which can be refilled at home or returned to retailers in exchange for a pre-filled replacement.
The purpose was “to save taxpayers the cost of disposing of used propane canisters, and to protect workers and communities from the fire and explosion risks posed by propane cylinders thrown away in our parks and beaches,” Laird said Thursday in a statement welcoming Bonta’s intervention.
Bonta said the state law “will protect workers and the environment from residual propane explosions and save local governments millions of tax dollars in waste management costs.” Once again, he said, the Trump administration “is trying to overrule California’s laws aimed at protecting public safety, health, and the environment.”
But President Donald Trump’s Department of Transportation says the state law would actually force consumers to purchase heavier and more expensive alternatives, and is inconsistent with waste-management regulations adopted under federal law.
“While the state’s radical leadership pushes burdensome regulations that raise prices and stifle consumer choice, the Trump administration is cutting red tape and protecting American families from pointless laws,” Paul Roberti, who heads the department’s Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration, said in announcing the administration’s legal action in September seeking to override SB1280.
Bonta countered Thursday that federal law has not interfered with the common use of refillable 20-gallon propane tanks to fuel backyard barbecue grills in Americans’ backyards for decades.
Under the law cited by the Department of Transportation, Bonta said, one of the department’s hazardous materials regulations already “authorizes refillable propane cylinders and refillable cylinders, which are widely available for sale.”
Published in the San Francisco Chronicle.